🥧 The Best Places to Buy Pumpkin Pies in Markham

Fall in Markham means cozy sweaters, crisp air, colourful leaves and of course, pumpkin pie season. Whether you’re getting ready for Thanksgiving, hosting a family dinner, or simply craving a slice of that warm, spiced goodness, Markham has plenty of local bakeries and cafes that make some of the best pumpkin pies in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA).

As a Markham Realtor who loves supporting local businesses, I’ve rounded up some of the top spots where you can find fresh, delicious pumpkin pies right here in our community.

🏆 1. Main Street Bakehouse

If you’re craving a fresh, homemade pumpkin pie in Markham, Main Street Bakehouse is the perfect place to start. Known for its handcrafted pastries, flaky crusts, and rich seasonal fillings, this local favourite captures the cozy taste of fall in every bite.

Their pumpkin pies are made from scratch with real pumpkin purée and a perfect blend of spices, never too sweet, never too heavy. Pair a slice with their signature latte or cappuccino for the ultimate autumn treat.

📍 Conveniently located on Main Street Unionville, this charming bakery café is a go-to spot for locals who love artisanal desserts, brunch, and warm community vibes.

🍂 2. Felix & Norton Café

Known for their artisan cookies, Felix & Norton also offers seasonal desserts, including their popular pumpkin pie during the fall months. It’s smooth, lightly spiced, and pairs beautifully with a latte from their in-house espresso bar.

📍 Situated near Downtown Markham, this café offers a cozy, modern vibe perfect for catching up with friends or taking a break from house hunting.

🎃 3. Dufflet Pastries (available at select Markham retailers)

If you’re a fan of Toronto’s iconic Dufflet Pastries, you can find their signature pumpkin pies at several local grocery stores and cafes in Markham. Made with fresh pumpkin purée, creamy texture, and just the right hint of cinnamon and nutmeg, these pies never disappoint.

📍 Look for them at local spots like Whole Foods Markham or Village Grocer, especially around Thanksgiving.

🧁 4. Bakery Nakamura

For something unique, try Bakery Nakamura, a Japanese-style bakery in J-Town Markham. While they’re best known for their cheesecakes and light pastries, their pumpkin pies and seasonal cakes bring a delicate, fluffy twist to this fall favourite.

📍 Located in the J-Town plaza, it’s a must-visit for anyone who appreciates high-quality desserts with an Asian influence.

🍰 5. The Village Grocer

No list of Markham bakeries is complete without mentioning The Village Grocer in Unionville. Their in-house bakery makes classic pumpkin pies, along with other seasonal desserts like pecan pie, pumpkin cheesecake, and fresh fruit tarts.

Their pies are made fresh daily, and they sell out quickly around Thanksgiving, so pre-ordering is highly recommended.

🥧 6. Patisserie Fleur

If you’re looking for a gourmet take on pumpkin pie, head to Patisserie Fleur. Known for its elegant pastries and cakes, this bakery creates beautifully presented pumpkin pies with buttery crusts and velvety fillings. It’s a must for anyone who appreciates artisanal desserts with a modern twist.

📍 Conveniently located near Highway 7, this shop is a favorite among Markham foodies.

🍁 A Taste of Fall in Every Slice

Pumpkin pie is more than a dessert, it’s a fall tradition that brings families together. Whether you’re new to Markham or have called this city home for years, exploring local bakeries is a delicious way to celebrate the season and support small businesses that make our community special.

As a local Markham Realtor, I love helping people discover not just their dream home but also the hidden gems that make our city so vibrant. From cozy cafés to family-friendly neighborhoods, Markham is full of warmth, flavour, and community spirit.

👨‍💼 Thinking of Moving to Markham?

If you’re considering buying or selling a home in Markham, I can help you navigate the market with confidence. Whether you’re looking for a charming home in Unionville, a luxury property in Angus Glen, or a family-friendly house in Cornell, I’ll guide you through every step.

📞 Contact Michael John Lau today your trusted Markham Realtor for personalized real estate advice, home evaluations, and expert insights.

Visit www.callmikelau.com to start your Markham home journey today.